I shop at Canadian Tire frequently, but only when the price is right. On occasion I have returned items. One was a made in China POS scissor Jack that had a safety affecting defect. That was when I discovered that the Country Hills Canadian Tire in Calgary would not accept a return from the Dalhousie Canadian Tire because the franchisees are different owners. WTF? LMAO. You have got to be kidding right? Regarding the driver’s license thing. Forget it. Once a DL number goes into a data retrieval system, or gets written onto dumpster fodder, your privacy is compromised. Period. If you think that is trivial, try Googling "Identity Theft".
If you have the receipt, the whole “Protect us from fraud” argument is ca-ca anyways. They have no justifiable reason to require your identity.
Before somebody puts my personal details (like Name, Birth Date, DL Number, or SIN) into a computer, or writes it on a slip that will end up in their dumpster unshredded, they need to do two things:
1) Convince me it is required by law or is a reasonable component of thier return policy.
2) Convince me that they have taken all the extraordinary and very hard to maintain security precautions necessary to protect that information from unauthorized access.
Since the keystone-cop clown show that has become the Calgary Canadian Tire operation has little hope of doing either, and since I usually keep my receipts, I only give them my “name of the day”, and of course, my “phone number of the day”. No stress, Everyone happy. Bob’s your uncle. In fact, on some days, I am Bob. Not once have they complained that the name on the receipt, or my credit card, does not match the "name of the day", nor that the phone numbers don’t match the name in thier database. They just add it to the other guy's name who was dumb enough to give it to them in the first place.
Frank, James, Alex, Monica, Bob
P.S. Regarding that guy who was ranting and swearing: Empty vessels make the loudest noise. I think your brain might have fallen out on that last curve. Run along now, and clean up your mess