Hey there,
It's the same guy who posted this 2 years ago. Still with CTC, except in a different store now, and in the summer months am a Garden Centre/Seasonal manager. After being in a few stores, the most recent especially, I've learned that the best way to do business is serve the customer. As long as we (the store), get our credit... we're going to help you out. As long as you're completely honest with us, we're going to help you out.
You used a vacuum cleaner, but didn't like how it worked? Most stores would tell you you can't return that since you used it. Well, not necessarily. If you come to me with that, and you're clearly honest that you used it once and it's just not doing the job, and you purchased it within 90 days, I won't just shut you down. Instead, I'll write it off as "defective". The store will still get the credit, and you get what you want (exchange or refund, your choice). After 90 days? I'll still do it for you, but most of these people are dishonest and trying to take advantage of a current sale. But whatever, we've probably made a lot of money off of you as a loyal customer, so I'll still take care of you. After 90 days, I'll give you an exchange. You want a refund? Sorry, can't do that after 90 days on a used and not necessarily defective item, but I'll still write it off as defective and give you a Canadian Tire giftcard for your next purchase.
Repair only warranty? No big deal. Most stores tell their customers that it's a repair only warranty. They're right, it is. But there are ways around that. I can take back the defective lawn mower or whatever this thing is, I'll get it repaired, and I'll sell it again at a reduced price. You see, I can claim the amount we had to take off of the price of the lawn mower through the corporation, with a simple "code 55" on the adjustacard. I can also get a full credit on the lawnmower from corporation, simply by putting a "code 50" on an adjusta card. No big deal. Same rule applies as before. If the purchase was recent, here's your refund, or you can exchange it. After 90 days, if repair isn't something you want to go through, I'll do an exchange.
The truth is, there is always a way around the policy for both the store and the customer. I'll tell you guys right now with full sincerity, every CT dealer wants their managers to do the best they can for the customer, such as the avenues discussed above. But, unfortunately, most managers don't get paid that well and many are extremely small minded. They follow the policy to the letter, at their own peril.
If you have a situation, and are wondering how it can be resolved, post it here. Go back to your Canadian Tire store that's giving you trouble and show them how it can work. There is always a way.
The one rule I always stress is the "receipt" or "proof of purchase". Tough to get around that one. However, if you purchased it by debit or credit, we can search it in the system within a certain amount of time. If you have a statement from your bank or credit card company, I'll accept that too. I need something to show me you bought this product, as theft and then then attempted returns are becoming more and more prevalent.